Eight cities across three states in the United States have fallen victim to a Magecart card skimming attack. In these attacks, their websites were compromised to host credit card skimmers which passed on the credit card information of residents to cybercriminals.
These sites all appear to have been built using Click2Gov, a web-based platform meant for use by local governments. It is used to provide services such as community engagement, issues reporting, and online payment for local goverments. Residents can use the platform to pay for city services, such as utilities. Breaches in these sites, however, are not new: In 2018 and 2019, the websites of several towns and cities using Click2Gov were compromised.
Figure 1. Credit card skimming attack chain
- Credit card information (card number, expiration date, CVV)
- Personal information (Name and contact address)
Our analysis of both the skimmer and the infrastructure used could not find any connections between this breach and the incidents in 2018 and 2019. Nevertheless, five of the eight cities were also affected in the previous breaches; we believe that these attacks started on April 10 of this year, and are still active.
Analysis of the card skimming attack
Unlike other skimmers which grab data on various types of payment forms, the skimmer used here is rather simple and only works on a Click2Gov payment form. No obfuscation or anti-debugging techniques were used. The skimmer hooks the submit event of the payment form; when a victim clicks the button to send the payment information, the skimmer will grab the information from the selected columns inside the payment form and immediately send the collected information to remote server via a HTTP POST request.
|Exfiltrated Data Type||Targeted Column ID||Exfiltration Request Schema|
|Credit card number||accountNumber||accountNumber|
|Credit card CVV number||cvv2||cvv|
|Credit card expiration year||expirationDate.year||year|
|Credit card expiration month||expirationDate.month||month|
|Credit card expiration date||expirationDate.date||date|
|First name of cardholder||firstName||firstName|
|Middle name of cardholder||middleInitial||middleInitial|
|Last name of cardholder||lastName||lastName|
|Contact address 1||contact.address1||address1|
|Contact address 2||contact.address2||address2|
|City of contact address||contact.city||city|
|State of contact address||contact.state||State|
|Zip code of contact address||contact.zip||ZipCode|
Table 1. Details of exfiltrated information
Background and attribution
Click2Gov has been hit by various breaches and attacks in the past. CentralSquare Technologies, its developer, released a 2018 statement concerning security issues on various locally hosted sites. Other researchers uncovered a breach of around 300,000 records from Click2Gov sites
Click2Gov at the end of that year. Another 2018 report showed a similar case where a site built using Click2Gov was targeted by an attacker to exfiltrate credit card information from its users. In 2019, another breach was discovered, where it became apparent that data from eight cities was being sold in the underground market.
It is not clear at this time if this attack which we identified is connected to the earlier breaches, since nothing about their technical details indicate a connection. The only connection is that five of the affected cities in the current incident were also affected in 2018; while two were included in the 2019 incident.
Credit card skimming attacks are still a major threat to online merchants. Victims not limited to only typical e-commerce sites. During 2019, we also saw that academic institutions and hotel chains were targeted by similar attacks. This time, the attacker targeted the websites of various local governments. This shows the importance of keeping payment portals secure to protect both an organization and its customers.
The following Trend Micro solutions protect users and businesses by blocking the scripts and preventing access to the malicious domains:
- Trend Micro™ Security
- Smart Protection Suites and Worry-Free™ Business Security
- Trend Micro Network Defense
- Hybrid Cloud Security
Indicators of Compromise (IoC)
|Credit Card Skimmer (detected as TrojanSpy.JS.MAGECART.G)|
|a7db455dc25d107caf8f74f7d4c492541c5d37c38bf68604a6e85b06b61af26a||Credit Card Skimmer (detected as TrojanSpy.JS.MAGECART.G)|
|https[:]//cdns-static[.]com/recurring.js||Credit Card Skimmer URL|
|https[:]//renew-analytics[.]com/recurring.js||Credit Card Skimmer URL|
|cdns-static[.]com||Credit Card Skimmer Domain|
|renew-analytics[.]com||Credit Card Skimmer Domain|